37 Comments
User's avatar
platinum speed-over-time's avatar

Fantastic essay, with some critical guiding points made along the way: "self-study must include the discipline’s foundational texts" and "research has to culminate."

Expand full comment
Rajendra Kshirsagar's avatar

Agree with Woolf. I am off OTTs/movies/TV shows/sports and I only read books. One of the most profound changes I have experienced has been a sense of calmness that was missing earlier.

Expand full comment
One Wandering Mind's avatar

Reading has gone down because of the addictive nature of our phones.

Amateur research is alive still, but often more confined to areas where there isn't a large equipment cost to entry. Software being the major one. A lot of open source I would consider amateur research. Then there are also the online communities you mentioned like reddit, stack overflow, twitter, discord servers, ect.

Because of many years of formal research and amateur, most of the low hanging fruit for discovery is gone. It remains where there is new technology or phenomena.

I do wonder how much amateur research there used to be. My first guess would be not that much. Assuming that most people did not have much leisure time where in they could do this research.

Expand full comment
Sylvana's avatar

I loved this. It sort of… how do I put it… it crystallised and organised faint notions that have been floating around my head for a while now. And I’m so appreciative of the way it’s written: clean, well-researched, actionable, and gently hopeful despite calling out the flaws in our culture. Also the foundation in Islamic principles? Yeah, I’m going to read this several more times and take notes. Thank you

Expand full comment
Sylvana's avatar

By the way, that sequence of “In this year, when such and such happened, this author worries about the future of reading” in The Long Century of the Last Reader section was brilliant. How it depicts the passage of time and the… using the rule of three and… yeah my eloquence has run out but that section right there was so shiny and I aspire to use storytelling tools as well as that

Expand full comment
Gálvez Caballero's avatar

Great read. It is notable to mention that "reading" and "reciting" were the same meaning in ancient times due to being the same act. Reading silently was developed in the middle Ages, and even then there are records of (I think St.Ambrose) amazed at watching someone watch pages and turn them without reading aloud. This is very interesting!

Expand full comment
Yassine khayati's avatar

Wonderful read! The Quran really did start with read as it is the thing that gets us close to god. It is a wonderful heartwarming thought that makes the universe makes sense

Expand full comment
Laura Moore's avatar

Absolutely stunning essay. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Bowen Tibbetts's avatar

Beautifully written. Thank you for this!

Expand full comment
Karen Knudson's avatar

This would be part of my Heaven.

Expand full comment
Julie Sullivan's avatar

They ARE still around. They’re all Wikipedia editors

Expand full comment
Valentina Sertić's avatar

Thank you for giving my way of life a name, many names, in fact. From now on, "leisurely researcher" will be part of my CV.

Expand full comment
Halimah Shaikh's avatar

This is amazing :)

Expand full comment
Sadik Kassim's avatar

I can sense divine inspiration in this essay—the content and style are truly beautiful. Thank you for this!

Expand full comment
mnemonixART's avatar

Great read!

Expand full comment
Robert Johnson's avatar

Ms. Mahmoud- thank you very much for this essay. I've been this person my entire adult life, but the thing that really hit home is at the end: to contribute research for the community. I've published essays in books, but I should - and can - do much, much more.

A tad spooky: your example of walking in the suburbs and wondering where did all this come from: I asked myself the same thing around age 25. I grew up in the suburbs of Los Angeles and this was one question that has kept me going for a long time: why did the Red Cars disappear? What about post-war government funding got the suburbs going? Why? How does the environment of the suburbs affect personality? When I was a kid and entered homes on my block, why did they all seem just like my house, only maybe turned 90 degrees here and there? Why did I only have one fellow black student my entire 12 years of primary schooling?

This never ends. But: I've never published a damned thing about all this. It's just endlessly interesting to me.

Your essay gets to heart of one of my obsessions: I'm never bored. But why does it seem almost everyone else is lost with dopamine hits and doomscrolling? My library card is one of my most cherished possessions. Why aren't more people using their cards? What does it mean to "get a life!"?

Expand full comment
Laura Moore's avatar

"This never ends. But: I've never published a damned thing about all this. It's just endlessly interesting to me."

Hi Robert, sounds like it's time for you to start a Substack! But seriously, look into creating a Substack as a notebook of sorts. Not to develop a "brand" or curate an identity but to participate in discourse. That's what I'm trying to do here and I think Substack is a really special place for it. Hopefully it doesn't become too commodified.

Expand full comment
Kathy Oneto's avatar

For me, your article serves as happy, inspiring serendipity. It's the second time this year that I've read and been called to "Research as Leisure Activity." It's a sign to me that this is what I'm longing to do. I appreciate your setting the stage to guide my next steps.

Expand full comment